Pope is against condoms! -updated-

Posted by


Are you surprised? I guess some people are… considering the controversy these days. Here’s a report from Vatican Radio:

Question by french journalist from France2 (TV) : Your Holiness, among the many ailments that Africa suffers from, there is in particular the expansion of Aids. The position of the Catholic church on how to fight against it is often considered as unrealistic and inefficient. Will you treat this subject during the voyage? Most Holy Father, could you possibly answer this question in French?

Benedict XVI: You speak Italian well… As a matter of fact, I would say the opposite. I think that the reality more efficient, more present, stronger in the struggle against Aids is in fact the Catholic Church, with its movements, with its various realities. I am thinking of the Sant’Egidio Community which has done much – in a visible or invisible manner – for the struggle against Aids, of the Camillians, of so many others, of all the nuns who attend the sick… I would say that this problem of Aids will not be overcome simply with money. It (money) is necessary, but if there lacks the soul knowing how to utilise it, then it doesn’t help, one cannot overcome by distributing condoms ; on the contrary, this increases the problem. The solution has to be a double one: first, humanising sexuality, i.e. a spiritual and human renewal with a new manner of behaviour with others, and secondly, a true friendship especially for those who suffer, an availability, with sacrifices, with personal renunciations, in order to be with the suffering. All these are factors that help and carry in them true and visible progress. This is why I would say our double force of renewing the human being from inside, giving him a spiritual and human force for a just behaviour in his conduct towards his own body and that of others, and the capacity to suffer with the suffering, to be present in testing situations. This seems the right answer, and the Church is doing it, thus offering a contribution of utmost importance. Let us give thanks for all those who do it.

Here’s an interesting commentary from Dave Trafford’ blog at CFRB News in Toronto. You can also follow him on Twitter.

What passes for debate in most arenas these days is ad hominem attacks at best; physical and emotional bullying at worst. Add that to the functional illiteracy of most “religious” debaters and…well…you understand why I don’t bother.

Just listen to the populist, hot button drivel being spewed over the Pope’s condoms comments today…

In the first example, the defenders of humanity are all in a lather because the Pope said precisely what we expect the Pope to say on the subject of condoms. Condom use is a non-starter for the Roman Catholic Pontiff even when it comes to the subject of AIDS/HIV prevention. The Church makes it quite clear, abstinence and fidelity in a relationship are the only guaranteed ways of preventing AIDS, and pregnancy for that matter.

The outrage is out of control because the Pope followed his well worn script, because he told us exactly what he thinks and believes.Things would have been calmer or more agreeable if he had lied?

The bottom line is, despite some poor timing at times, B16 is right on the mark. We are deluding ourselves if we think that condoms are the real solution to AIDS in Africa… or for that matter anywhere. If the issue is that women are forced into sexual slavery and forced to have sex with infected men… well, the answer is not the condom, but it’s getting some sense into men to respect women and treat them as a gift from God…as we all are.  The Pope is challinging us with a big picture vision of humanity… and people don’t want to be challenged to change. Just give me a quick fix.

updates…… also consider the commentary in The Telegraph, UK. or this one also here on the AIDS Mafia.


  1. I really pity the Holy Father and all the flak he’s taken lately. All this vitriol spewed against a learned, cultured, gentle old man with a depth of spirituality and wisdom that most of us can only dream of. All this flak for a job he didn’t want in the first place. I trust the Good Lord will give him the strength to overcome the disappointment and frustration that he must surely experience.
    I read an article recently that quoted an African bishop who said something to the effect that he wished the western world would stop sending Africa condoms; that Africa is buried in a mountain of condoms. So one lonely voice on the world stage speaks up and says condoms aren’t he answer and it’s a scandal. Can we even entertain the idea that there might be just a little wisdom in a comment that runs so counter to popular opinion, intuition and group think?
    One of my favourite comments from JPII was that the Catholic Church imposes nothing, she only proposes. To me, this condom brouhaha is an example of that. The Holy Father speaks out loud what the Church holds is true with the hope that people will listen and experience a conversion. It imposes nothing. People continue to make their own decisions. For anyone to suggest that Church teaching might have the slightest thing to do with a situation such as a married man choosing against condom use while using a prostitute is absurd. Trust me, if you are already committing adultery and participating in the victimization of a woman by paying her for sex, the last thing that crosses your mind is Church teaching about the wrongs of a rubber sheath. And if anyone believes that Church teaching has led to the supply of even one less condom anywhere, I refer to the comments of the African bishop above.

  2. What’s sad I think is that the Pope speaks out against what the secular world is a given right. Sex when you want it and how you want it. Any common sense argument to their mantra has to be attacked. The pope is speaking about true love and respect for the human being. Rather than see the other as a sexual object we should see them as God’s creation.

    The true ignorance here is from the condom police! They won’t even hear what the Church teaches. Read Humanae Vitae and then argue against the merits of that. If they can.

  3. All what you are saying is great …. but the Romans have other stories to tell you … stories which take place after midnight which … if true ….would not be very rejoicing and n-certainly not in line whith the VAtican teaching … pot calling the kettle black ….

  4. I was rather hopefull that you wouldn’t be censoring after your comments on your last post. I guess you are back to your old tricks.

  5. Edward C. Green, director of the AIDS Prevention Research Project at the Harvard Center for Population and Development Studies, states that the evidence confirms that the Pope is correct in his assessment that condom distribution exacerbates the problem of AIDS. “The pope is correct,” Green told National Review Online Wednesday, “or put it a better way, the best evidence we have supports the pope’s comments.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s