U.S. Catholics decline

Posted by

The big news these day is a new study in the U.S. that shows that many Catholics are leaving the Church in favour of more evangelical or charismatic faith communities. Church numbers are actually being sustained by immigration of Catholics. There seems to be a thirst for a greater sense of community and more intensely personal experience of God that other faith groups seem better positioned to provide. It makes me wonder whether our Church’s recent debates about the liturgy and the multitude of “minor” changes to the mass in the next few years will impress the faithful as the kind of meaningful change they were hoping for. It’s not to say that we shouldn’t improve the liturgy. The question is whether it is really the key or one of the key issues we are facing. I don’t know about you but I would rather spend all of that energy and time on continuing education of the clergy on preaching! But then it’s not up to me.

I don’t think that this issue is contained to the U.S. It seems that in Canada the situation is a little bit different. Many, many Catholics here retain their identity as Catholic, but simply don’t go to any Church. They just stay home. Our Archbishop in Toronto, Tom Collins, speaks of the need to reach out not just to those in the pews… the gathered… but the many Catholics who are at home… the scattered. I think it is crucial. Reginald Bibby, a Canadian sociologist, has written quite a bit about this and calls us to reach out to the scattered as they are simply waiting to be invited home.

Such invitations cannot be just through formal programmes or events. It cannot come just from bishops and priests, religious or deacons. It’s got to come from the joy and enthusiasm of every Catholic! Take a look at the example and message of the new Bishop of Pittsburg, PA who challenged his diocese. It’s a 2o minute homily, but you can fast forward at times. It’s a great reflection on how the faith spread like fire after the Resurrection. It’s worth a listen.


  1. It’s all in the numbers I guess. I think you will find this study by Inside Catholic interesting. http://insidecatholic.com/Joomla/images/stories/diocesan_report.pdf

    My Diocese is faced with next to the worst ratio of priests to adherents 1 to 10,000 & is the 3rd highest rate of growth -140% Over 10 years. My old diocese in New jersey has the 5th worst adult conversion rate in the country and zero ordinations.

    Let me know your thoughts on it.

    I had a discussion with a protestant who is a professional church marketer. We disagreed on just about everything. Sound systems, big screen TV’s, bring in Christian rock stars etc. all bring them in according to him.

    The question is does that help in keeping them in? For me the greatest thing the church can do is get the local church to practice the corporal & spiritual works of mercy and the nets will break gathering them in. I think since Vat II we do a fairly good job on the corporal, but we’re utter failures in the spiritual works of mercy.

  2. Fr. Rick, I will agree with Archbishop Collins. Maybe it’s good repeating to mention this in the pulpit as a general type of apostolate or ministry.

    I also agree with you QUICKBEAM…. The heart of the the faith community is the “spiritual encountering of the “Living God.” or prayer in a more personal but communal

    It sounds moving backward. But, I believed that this keeps us grounded and gives deeper meaning in our progress/development as a Church. thanks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s